Skip to content

Eighth Circuit Invalidates Regulation II: What It Means for Debit Card Interchange Fees

November 23, 2026

On October 26, 2026, the Eighth Circuit issued a decision that has the potential to change how much interchange fees banks can charge on debit card transactions. While there might be more to come with this case, as it stands, the Federal Reserve Board’s (“FRB”) debit card interchange regulation has been invalidated.

Background on the Durbin Amendment

The Durbin Amendment—part of the Dodd-Frank Wall Street Reform and Consumer Protection Act—authorized the FRB to prescribe regulations to keep debit card interchange fees reasonable and proportional to the cost incurred by the debit card issuer. The Durbin Amendment does not apply to debit card issuers with less than $10 billion in assets; those “small” issuers are free to charge interchange fees that exceed the FRB’s cap.

In 2011, the FRB implemented the Durbin Amendment by issuing Regulation II. Regulation II capped the interchange fee at 21 cents plus 0.05% of the transaction. The regulation also allowed for a 1 cent increase if the debit card issuer implemented fraud-prevention standards.

Eighth Circuit Decision and Corner Post

A truck stop and convenience store in North Dakota named Corner Post challenged Regulation II under the Administrative Procedure Act (“APA”). The case was stuck in various procedural states for nearly 5 years before the Eighth Circuit handed down this decision. The wait, however, was worth it for Corner Post, as the Eighth Circuit found that the FRB exceeded its authority under the APA in issuing Regulation II and invalidated Regulation II.  The Eighth Circuit focused on the FRB’s failure to consider the incremental cost of a debit card transaction as required by the statute. The court also questioned the FRB’s inclusion of certain fixed costs in setting the interchange fee cap. The court decided that the Durbin Amendment’s text did not permit the FRB to consider these items.

As it stands, Regulation II will be vacated in mid-December of 2026. It is possible that the FRB will request rehearing en banc with the full Eighth Circuit, which would delay vacatur until the full court acts. Alternatively, the FRB could potentially appeal the ruling to the Supreme Court, which would also delay vacatur until the Supreme Court acts. If the FRB takes that route, there is a reasonable chance that the Supreme Court would hear the case. There is now a circuit split between the Eighth Circuit and the D.C. Circuit, who rejected a similar challenge to Regulation II in 2014. The Sixth Circuit is also considering a parallel case challenging Regulation II, which will further entrench the circuit split. Given the circuit split and the significant economic stakes of this case, this is the rare case that the Supreme Court could take up.

Implications of the Eighth Circuit’s Decision

If the FRB does not file for rehearing en banc or file an appeal with the Supreme Court, Regulation II will no longer be in effect as of mid-December 2026. Unless the FRB acts immediately to issue a new regulation, there will be no regulatory cap on debit card interchange fees. Debit card issuers could start charging more—or less—than 21 cents per transaction.

The stakes of Regulation II are enormous, as shown by trade groups’ reactions to the decision. The Merchant Payments Group cheered the Eighth Circuit decision, stating that the FRB had set debit card interchange fees higher than the Durbin Amendment allows. In contrast, banking trade groups criticized the decision, stating that the decision will make banking services more expensive.

Both merchants and debit card issuers will follow the FRB’s chosen path with interest, as both continuing the litigation or issuing a new regulation could change the economics of debit payments. Merchants will hope the result is that the FRB lowers the interchange fee cap to make debit card transactions cheaper. Debit card issuers will hope that the FRB maintains a similar fee cap to preserve the economics of the debit card system.

Regulatory Uncertainty Following Supreme Court Decisions

This case also highlights the regulatory uncertainty following the Supreme Court’s recent decisions in Loper Bright and Corner Post that changed administrative law. Because of Loper Bright, federal courts no longer reflexively defer to agencies when interpreting statutes. The Eighth Circuit cited Loper Bright five times in its decision, demonstrating how important Loper Bright is in APA litigation.

Loper Bright will also impact any changes the FRB makes to Regulation II. Any changes will be hotly contested, and an updated regulation will be challenged in court again. The FRB may find it difficult to craft a regulation that all interested parties will accept, and Loper Bright means that a court reviewing the regulation would not defer to the FRB’s interpretation of the Durbin Amendment.

Moreover, the Supreme Court’s earlier decision in the Corner Post litigation now allows challenges to a regulation at any time. Prior to that decision, APA challenges to regulations generally had to be brought within six years of the regulation being issued. The Supreme Court’s decision changed that, holding instead that a plaintiff can challenge a regulation if it was harmed within six years of filing, regardless of when the regulation was issued, creating regulatory uncertainty for almost every regulated industry.

The combination of the Supreme Court’s Loper Bright and Corner Post decisions has now plunged the debit card payments industry into that uncertainty. It is possible that there is no Regulation II and no cap on debit card interchange fees for a substantial period. Any future, high-stakes regulation is likely to draw an APA challenge, resulting in uncertainty for regulated entities and an uphill battle for federal agencies to engage in effective and necessary rulemaking.

Conclusion

The Eighth Circuit’s decision has the potential to upend the debit card ecosystem. By 2027, the FRB’s Regulation II may not be in effect, allowing debit card issuers to charge any interchange fee they want. This could very well raise the cost of debit card transactions—costs that merchants likely will pass on to consumers. While many merchants, including Corner Post, believe interchange fees are too high, it is possible this litigation may have the opposite effect.

No matter the outcome, the decision may plunge a significant part of the U.S. payment system into chaos. Debit payments account for roughly 30% of payments in the U.S., and interchange fees account for approximately 11% of banks’ non-interest income. The debit card industry is a huge industry, and its economics may hang in the balance of this litigation and the FRB’s response to it.

This publication is intended for general informational purposes only and does not constitute legal advice or a solicitation to provide legal services.  The information in this publication is not intended to create, and receipt of it does not constitute, a lawyer-client relationship.  Readers should not act upon this information without seeking professional legal counsel.  The views and opinions expressed herein represent those of the individual author only and are not necessarily the views of Clark Hill PLC.  Although we attempt to ensure that postings on our website are complete, accurate, and up to date, we assume no responsibility for their completeness, accuracy, or timeliness.

Subscribe for the latest

Subscribe