On October 29, 2026, the U.S. Equal Employment Opportunity Commission (EEOC) announced that its commissioners had voted to rescind its 2012 guidance on employers’ use of arrest and conviction records in hiring, promotion, and termination decisions.
The guidance, issued in April 2012, warned that criminal background checks could violate Title VII of the Civil Rights Act if they disproportionately excluded applicants based on race or national origin without sufficient business justification (a “disparate impact” theory). It (1) encouraged employers to consider the seriousness of the offense, the time that had passed, and whether the conduct was relevant to the position; (2) recommended individualized assessments giving applicants an opportunity to explain their criminal history before the employer made a final decision; (3) advised that an arrest alone is insufficient evidence of criminal wrongdoing, although an employer may consider evidence of the underlying conduct if relevant to the position; and (4) cautioned that a blanket ban on hiring individuals with criminal convictions could violate Title VII if it disproportionately excluded applicants of a particular race and lacked a sufficient connection to the job.
The rescission follows President Trump’s April 2025 executive order directing federal agencies to deprioritize enforcement of disparate-impact liability.
What Has Not Changed
EEOC Chair Andrea Lucas stated that rescinding the guidance “does not give employers license to engage in unlawful discrimination.” She added that Title VII continues to prohibit discrimination based on race or national origin, including employment requirements used as substitutes for intentional bias. Here are some important items that employers should keep in mind:
- Disparate-impact claims remain available. Congress codified disparate-impact liability under Title VII in the Civil Rights Act of 1991. A shift in agency enforcement priorities does not prevent applicants or employees from bringing these claims in court.
- Intentional discrimination remains a priority. The EEOC has stated it will continue to pursue claims where criminal history screening is applied inconsistently or used as a pretext for race or national origin discrimination.
- Obligations under the Fair Credit Reporting Act still apply. Employers that use third-party background checks must comply with the Act’s procedural requirements. Before obtaining a report, the employer generally must provide a clear, standalone disclosure and obtain the applicant’s written authorization. Before taking adverse action based on a report, the employer must give the applicant a pre-adverse-action notice that includes a copy of the report and a summary of rights, allow a reasonable period for the applicant to respond, and then provide a separate adverse-action notice. These requirements are unaffected by the EEOC’s action and are a frequent source of class litigation.
- State and local fair-chance laws still apply. Some jurisdictions restrict when and how employers may ask about criminal history. These requirements are unaffected by the EEOC’s action, and in many states and cities they go further than federal law. Some jurisdictions require an individualized assessment, limit how far back an employer may look, or require a written rationale before rejecting an applicant based on a conviction. For example, under the Illinois Human Rights Act, an employer generally may not refuse to hire someone simply because that person has been arrested. An employer, however, may consider reliable information showing that the applicant actually engaged in the conduct underlying the arrest, even if the applicant was never convicted.
- Negligent-hiring risk still applies. Declining to screen carries its own exposure. An employer that fails to conduct a reasonable background check may face negligent-hiring or negligent-retention claims if an employee later causes foreseeable harm. The decision whether and how to screen should weigh this risk alongside the risk of a discrimination claim.
- Collective bargaining obligations may apply. For a unionized workforce, criminal-history screening practices can be a mandatory subject of bargaining. Rules of conduct and the discipline or discharge of bargaining-unit employees are generally mandatory subjects, so an employer typically may not unilaterally change screening practices affecting current employees without first giving the union notice and an opportunity to bargain. Screening outside applicants before hire is generally treated as a permissive subject, but any practice tied to a collective bargaining agreement should be reviewed before any change is implemented.
Impact on Employers
It is permissible to keep existing procedures in place. Employers may continue using lawful screening practices adopted under the 2012 EEOC guidance. A practice that utilizes job-related screening criteria and individualized assessments remains the strongest defense to a disparate-impact or pretext claim.
Confirm screening criteria are job-related. Make sure any criminal history restrictions are tied to the duties of the position and consider the nature of the offense and the time elapsed. For example, a 30-year-old applicant for an administrative assistant position was convicted of stealing groceries when she was 18. At the time, her mother was struggling with drug addiction, her father had died, and she was responsible for supporting herself and her two younger siblings. Automatically rejecting this applicant based on a 12-year-old, nonviolent offense committed under difficult circumstances, with little connection to the duties of the role, could expose the employer to a disparate-impact claim, while an individualized assessment would allow the employer to make a defensible, job-related decision.
Apply policies consistently. Uniform application and documentation of decisions are critical to defending against intentional discrimination claims, which remain an EEOC enforcement focus.
Check state and local requirements. Confirm compliance with any fair-chance or “ban-the-box” laws in each jurisdiction where you hire.
Conclusion
The EEOC’s rescission of the 2012 guidance signals a change in federal enforcement priorities, not a change in the underlying law. Title VII, the Fair Credit Reporting Act, and state and local fair-chance requirements all remain in force, and both disparate-impact and intentional-discrimination claims remain available to applicants and employees. Employers should also remain mindful of the independent risk of negligent hiring. For most employers, the prudent course is to maintain lawful, job-related screening practices with individualized assessments, apply them consistently, document the basis for decisions, and confirm compliance with the requirements of each jurisdiction in which they hire.
If you have any questions or would like further information, please reach out to Lauren Smith, Lmsmith@clarkhill.com, or another member of Clark Hill’s nationally recognized Labor & Employment law team.
This publication is intended for general informational purposes only and does not constitute legal advice or a solicitation to provide legal services. The information in this publication is not intended to create, and receipt of it does not constitute, a lawyer-client relationship. Readers should not act upon this information without seeking professional legal counsel. The views and opinions expressed herein represent those of the individual author only and are not necessarily the views of Clark Hill PLC. Although we attempt to ensure that postings on our website are complete, accurate, and up to date, we assume no responsibility for their completeness, accuracy, or timeliness.