Skip to content

Clark Hill’s Michael Croghan Secures Judgment in Earnout Litigation

January 18, 2024

    Clark Hill litigation member Michael Croghan recently secured a $2.4 million judgment in the U.S. District Court for the District of Delaware.

    The case stems from the sale of a COVID-tracking Software-as-a-Service business in 2021. In May 2023, Clark Hill initiated litigation on behalf of the seller to recover money damages for breach of the purchase agreement’s earnout provision. The lawsuit alleged that the buyer invested little to no resources to generate revenues or grow the COVID-tracking business post-close, completely changed its business model from a subscription health tracking service to speculation in the lithium mining industry, and changed its name during a critical phase of the earnout period. After a hearing to establish damages during which Croghan presented the seller’s expert witness, United States District Judge Richard Andrews entered judgment for the full amount sought.

    “This was an important win for our client. The testimony of our expert witness was clear that it would have hit the full earnout if the defendant had not violated the post-closing operational covenants. Earnouts can serve an important function in M&A, but post-closing operational provisions are critical,” Croghan said.

    Clark Hill attorneys Michael Croghan, Molly DiBianca, and Nicole Prefontaine represented the client in this matter.

    Subscribe for the latest

    Subscribe

    Related

    Legal Updates

    Intellectual Property Rights and Instruments of Service

    Frequently on construction projects, design professionals such as architects and engineers are retained to invest substantial professional skill, time, and resources in creating drawings, specifications, calculations, models, and other documents. These materials are commonly known as “instruments of service” and are often mischaracterized as simple deliverables. However,  instruments of service embody design decisions, technical knowledge, original expression, and, increasingly, complex digital information.  

    Explore more
    Legal Updates

    The FTC Personalized Pricing Inquiry Turn Toward Compensation

    The Federal Trade Commission (FTC) has expanded its focus on personalized pricing beyond consumer transactions and into worker compensation. Through a new inquiry targeting major airlines, ride-share companies, and food-delivery platforms, the FTC is examining how companies use personal data, algorithms, and other technologies to determine both consumer pricing and gig-worker pay. This development signals a significant shift in regulatory scrutiny and raises important compliance considerations for businesses navigating a growing patchwork of state and local personalized pricing laws.

    Explore more
    Legal Updates

    New Trade Petitions Target Certain Shopping Carts and Parts Thereof from China, Alleging Dumping Margins of Up to 343%

    On October 28, 2026, U.S. producers filed antidumping and countervailing duty petitions on certain shopping carts and parts thereof from China with the Department of Commerce and the U.S. International Trade Commission. The petitions allege dumping margins ranging from 165% to 343% and subsidies above the de minimis level.

    Explore more

    The Clark Hill approach is equally pragmatic and growth-minded, which is why we understand our clients’ toughest business challenges. Our multidisciplinary, global team of advisors focuses on smart legal solutions, delivered simply.

    © 2026 Clark Hill PLC.