Clark Hill

Government & Public Affairs Update

July 28, 2009

 

 

 

Government & Public Affairs Team

 

R. Daniel Beattie

Alan L. Canady

Delbert J. Chenault

Roderick S. Coy

Denise Ilitch

Andrew C. Richner

Donald F. Tucker

Reginald M. Turner
John Van Fossen, Practice Group Leader

Lucius A. Vassar
Chris Wagner

 

 

Offices

 

Birmingham, MI

Detroit, MI

Grand Rapids, MI

Lansing, MI

Chicago, IL

Phoenix, AZ

Washington, DC 

  

 

 

Democrats Forced to Revise Timeline for Health Care Reform Legislation

With the Senate openly conceding it will not produce a bill before the President's August 7 goal and Democratic Leadership in the House unwilling to bypass the Energy and Commerce Committee to bring the bill directly to the floor, the earliest Democrats will have health care reform legislation on the floor of either chamber will likely be September.

A group of Republican and Democratic Senators on the Senate Finance Committee has been in negotiations to produce a bipartisan bill that the Committee and full Senate can support.  The negotiations are dragging on longer than anticipated but the legislation is starting to take shape, although negotiators are quick to point out that nothing has been finalized and that a deal is not imminent.

Yesterday, one of the Senators participating in the Finance discussions, Senator Olympia Snowe (R-ME), confirmed that the group has ruled out including an employer mandate and a government-run public option.  Instead, the bill would likely include a requirement for businesses with 50 or more employees to contribute to the cost of tax credits for eligible workers in an exchange.

"We want to make sure [employees] continue to access that coverage through their employers, " Snowe said.  "We don't want to undermine that or create a perverse incentive where employers drop their coverage because their employees could potentially get subsidies through the exchange, for example."

If a compromise is reached within the Committee and the final legislation takes such a form, it would stand in stark contrast from the bill the Senate Health, Education, Labor and Pensions (HELP) Committee approved on a party-line vote on July 15, which includes individual and employer mandates and a public option.

Senate Republicans are pessimistic that the legislative process will yield a health care reform package that they can support.  Many have wondered how a moderate bill out of the Finance Committee can survive after merging with the HELP bill and a conference with a potentially liberal House bill.  The three Republican Senators in  the Finance negotiations have sought assurances from Senate Majority Leader Harry Reid (D-NV) that the Finance legislation will be treated as the primary Senate floor vehicle, but Reid has not yet made a decision.

Nevertheless, a deal seems near in Finance and its Chairman, Senator Max Baucus (D-MT), has assured Reid that the Committee will begin to mark up a health care bill before the Senate adjourns on August 7.

In the House Energy and Commerce Committee, Chairman Henry Waxman (D-CA) is trying to strike a deal with seven Blue Dog Democrats on that Committee that would allow a markup to move forward tomorrow.  Blue Dog Democrats emerged from discussions with the Chairman this afternoon but did not indicate what their final position on the bill will be.  They indicated that among other cost cutting measures proposed, Waxman offered to reduce the subsidies that would be provided to lower-income Americans. Under the current bill, anyone making four times the poverty level would be eligible for government assistance in purchasing insurance. However, it is unclear whether  Waxman's overtures will be enough to gain the support of the deficit-focused group.  Regardless of what happens in the Committee this week, floor debate on the eventual bill will almost certainly be delayed until September.

 

 

If you have any questions concerning these issues, please contact Chris Wagner at 202.772.0924 or cwagner@clarkhill.com.

 

 

To find out more about Clark Hill and our Government & Public Affairs Practice Group, visit clarkhill.com or call 800.949.3124

 

 

Safe Unsubscribe

This email was sent to jhenderson@clarkhill.com by shernly@clarkhill.com.

Clark Hill PLC | 500 Woodward Ave | Suite 3500 | Detroit | MI | 48226